Announcement
The Idol's Eye is a boutique online retailer specialized in antique and vintage diamond engagement rings, selling on Etsy since 2015. Despite the proliferation of low cost, low quality reproductions on the market, when you purchase from The Idol's Eye you can rest assured that you will receive a genuine antique or vintage find handcrafted lovingly by fine jewelers of the past to the highest standards from the world's most durable, high-quality materials. This makes them a truly sustainable choice, worthy of handing down from generation to generation.
Featured items
Items
All Items
Reviews
-
Eric on Mar 6, 2024
5 out of 5 starsAmazing ring, fast delivery, exactly as described. I had it appraised and it appraised for more than the price I paid for it. Great communication from Tara. Thank you!
The Idol's responded on Mar 6, 2024
Thank you so much Eric for your kind review, and you're most welcome! I'm glad the appraisal went as expected, and even more so that you're happy with the ring. I hope you'll be back to my shop again in future!
-
Sandy on Mar 1, 2024
5 out of 5 starsAfter buying from this shop many years back, I revisited them on a whim and found they had just the right anniversary gift for my wife. She couldn't be happier with the superior quality workmanship of the item, and I'm delighted at having found yet another wonderful and authentic vintage item from this cool shop!
The Idol's responded on Mar 2, 2024
Thank you so much Sandy for your kind review, and I'm thrilled that you found the perfect anniversary gift in my shop! I wish you and your wife a wonderful anniversary, and sincerely hope to have the pleasure of your patronage again!
-
selena43 on Feb 23, 2024
5 out of 5 starsJust beautiful and authentic. I love the period from the late teens and the early 1960’ - art, jewelry, painting, music and on an on. Thank for offering this wonderful ring. I am so happy to be its current caretaker! 🌼🌼🌼
The Idol's responded on Feb 24, 2024
Thank you so much Selena for being such a wonderful customer! It's such a joy to encounter true lovers of antique and vintage jewelry such as yourself and I hope your rings will bring you happiness and inspiration forever!
-
selena43 on Feb 16, 2024
5 out of 5 starsLovely, sweet ring. Store owner kept in touch with me and everything worked out perfectly!!! Thank you
The Idol's responded on Feb 16, 2024
Thank you so much Selena for your generous review! I'm delighted that you're happy with your purchase, and very much hope to have the pleasure of your patronage again!
-
TMW on Feb 15, 2024
5 out of 5 starsJust ecstatic about the ring! It’s lovely in person.
The Idol's responded on Feb 15, 2024
Thank you so much Trennicia for your kind review! It is a very beautiful ring, and I'm thrilled that it went to a loving home!
-
Hieronymus on Jan 27, 2024
5 out of 5 starsI'm thrilled with this purchase, which was better than the listing photos suggested, and replete with quality craftsmanship typical of vintage fine jewelry from the Art Deco era. Awesome little shop, and if anyone out there is on the fence about buying on Etsy given the torrent of dropshippers and cheap knock-off items, you can absolutely trust this seller. Would definitely buy from again!
The Idol's responded on Feb 15, 2024
Thank you so much for your kind review and for recommending my shop! Reviews like yours mean so much to us! I hope the ring brings great joy to you and yours for many years to come!
-
Ben on Jan 24, 2024
5 out of 5 starsI was beginning to think there weren't any true vintage engagement rings on Etsy anymore, but then I somehow stumbled across this seller. I couldn't be more pleased with the item, which was as quality as a gorgeous diamond ring can get, and communication was excellent, which assuaged my concerns. The item arrived super fast, which was a bonus. Wouldn't hesitate to recommend to anyone looking for a legitimate seller of vintage engagement rings on Etsy!
The Idol's responded on Jan 26, 2024
Thank you so much Ben for your thoughtful review! It means so much to us! It's our greatest joy to find homes for all of our special vintage items with customers who will truly cherish them!
-
Harry on Jan 3, 2024
5 out of 5 starsI knew my girlfriend would want a vintage ring and something a little different. This ring fit the bill! It's really unique and special! Item was as described in the photos and description, and the ring arrived quickly in a nice gift box and with a really nice hand-written thank you card. Really happy with the whole experience. Thank you!
The Idol's responded on Jan 4, 2024
Thank you so much, Harry, for your kind review! I'm so glad this special ring has found a loving home with you and your girlfriend, and please don't hesitate to contact us if you ever need help finding another special jewelry item in the future!
-
Randall on Dec 22, 2023
5 out of 5 starsGreat stuff really pretty ring
The Idol's responded on Dec 23, 2023
Thank you so much Randall for your positive feedback, and I'm delighted that you are happy with your ring! Seasons greetings to you and yours from The Idol's Eye!
-
Amber on Dec 9, 2023
5 out of 5 starsThis business is outstanding! I didn't need customer service, but I know if I did, they would be there to help with any issue. The ring I purchased was exactly as described. Shipping was fast and I was informed with tracking info as well. If you are thinking about purchasing from them, don't delay. Would buy again from them without hesitation. Love my purchase and was happy to support a small business in the process!
The Idol's responded on Dec 10, 2023
Thank you so much Amber for your kind words! I do believe that a successful business is built on outstanding customer service, and I'm deeply grateful to you for recommending us. Most of all, I'm delighted that you're happy with your ring, and hope it will only become more meaningful to you with the years!
Updates
About TheIdolsEye
Fine Antique and Vintage Jewelry and Engagement Rings from the Storied Past
Shop members
-
Tara
Owner, Curator
Tara has an Art History degree from Columbia University and a degree in Fashion Design from Parsons School of Design. She is a scholar, a designer, and a skilled maker of things. Her love of antique jewelry is a natural culmination of her love for art history, fashion, and the design process from concept to execution. Over the years she's acquired an extensive knowledge of antique jewelry periods and values, gemstones and minerals, and historical jewelry-making techniques, and she's thrilled to share her knowledge and passions with others through her shop.
Shop policies
Shipping
Customs and import taxes
Payment options
Returns & exchanges
Cancellations
More information
Frequently asked questions
Do you offer layaway plans?
We're happy to create a custom layaway plan for you on certain items. Please convo us for details.
Do you accept returns?
Yes, we accept returns. We want you to be completely happy with your item. If you're not, we'll gladly accept a return, provided the item is in undamaged and unaltered condition (see next FAQ regarding alterations). To return an item, please contact us within 7 days of receipt to receive instructions for your return. We ask that we receive the item back within 14 days of your receipt of the item. Buyer is responsible for paying return shipping cost, including insurance for the full value of the item in case of loss or damage in transit. Upon receipt of the item in undamaged and unaltered condition, we will issue a refund in the original form of payment for the full amount. We cannot provide a refund on items lost during return transit.
Can I return an item that has been altered?
Please note that items must be returned to us in "as received" condition in order to be eligible for refund. We do not accept returns on items that have been polished, resized, or altered in any way, so please be sure your item is "the one" before making any alterations.
Do you offer resizing?
We prefer not to offer resizing on online orders, as we cannot measure your ring size in person for the best accuracy. However, if you urgently need resizing for your purchase, please convo us for resizing pricing. Please note that items that have been resized are considered custom orders, and are no longer eligible for return, so please be sure your item is "the one" before resizing.
Gift wrapping and packaging
All of our items ship in a velvet-lined jewelry box, packaged inside an outer box for added protection.
**Please note that the "This order includes a gift" option at checkout indicates that you do not want an invoice showing the price to be inlcuded in your package. It is not an option for gift wrapping. As none of our items ship with an invoice out of discretion, please help us avoid confusion by not checking this box.
Gift wrapping can be arranged for an additional fee. If you would like gift wrapping for your order, please convo me for details.
Gift notes are offered free of charge. If you would like to add a gift note, please include the text of the message in the "note to seller" area.
Seller details
Captcha failed to load. Try using a different browser or disabling ad blockers.